MOVIE : NEGERI 5 MENARA - REVIEW from ME

Almost all indonesian were proud seeing the incoming NEGERI 5 MENARA film, they proud cause the novel were success inside and outside of the indonesia
so let me review it from my amateur, otodidac cinematography (hei.. cine..whaaaaat??  well actually this is free right to blog, am i right - hihihi)

Story of Negeri 5 menara
starts with alif who were pointed to continue school at religion islamic school that called "pesantren" , his life dream were changing, his friendship too developing him to be a work hard people as in this film there are one statement in arabic "man jadda wa jada" (sorry if i wrote it with faulty), which mean "hard work determine success" or "keep struggle till end".

and this is my own review,
let's say all the badway

1. st fault (friends of alif makes an eye gaze to contact the director in scene after the drink milk) - it might be the actor were a newbie
2. nd fault the read of letter from alif's friend (the backsound of letter say "....kondisi sekarang ini" while the letter it self written just "kondisi ini" there are extra word.
3. rd.. The very clear mistaken when alif hv a jounalis time asking the kyai.. The questions list in the book that alif hands on were exactly a blank note. (i see it clearly on movies) well that's dissapointment for me
4. th fault is the ending scenario were actually a lil bit strange, it's just like there are jumping scenario, from little actor to be an adult actor... kinda dissapointment for me to.

let's say the bestway

1. the setting clearly was the true story telling in the novel
2. the supporting actor (friends of alif) performing good act
3. the simple story itself to define success , struggle and hard working

well i don't have the right to score this film, but if i have to make a scale , i will give 3.5 from 5 scale :)